TBS Crossfire Vs. FrSkt R9 – Initial thoughts
I’ve had Crossfire for a couple of months now and am pretty impressed. There are a couple of things it could do better; like staying at 10mW until it gets its initial bind with the receiver. But overall it’s a great system. Its biggest downfall is the price. The module is £100 or £200 depending on which version you go for. The receivers start at £35 all the way up to £120!
However, with the FrSky R9 system the module is priced, I believe, at around £80-90 with a receiver. The receivers on their own are priced between £18 and £45. I say I believe the price is around £80-90 because at the moment FrSky have an offer on. For the R9M module with an R9 MM receiver it’s £30!! This promotion, which has been on for most of September 2018, was fuelled by TBS. Trappy threw his toys out the pram over the R9 system, because he believes he invented the dipole antenna. Also that only TBS can use a chipset available to everyone. Not the first time Trappy has accused people of cloning when they haven’t, it just makes TBS look bad. For £30, I couldn’t say no!
Anyway, politics aside, how do these products stack up? I’ve not flown with the R9 system yet, so this is purely based on the setup and ease of use. I have the full Crossfire module. But I do believe that this will be a closer run thing with the Micro Tx.
Hardware
CRSF 2 – R9 3
What’s included
This is a tricky one, so I’m calling it a draw. With the Crossfire, you get the module, all the cables you need to get it to work with your transmitter, and a tired and tested Immortal T antenna. With the R9M you could get a half decent antenna, or one that’s been found to be a bit dodgy. On the other hand, the FrSky module comes with a receiver, so that squares it up. Speaking of the receivers, FrSky have uninverted ports on their new receivers, about bloody time! In all honesty, I don’t want to be carrying 2 antennas with me. So I’ll be using an RP-SMA to SMA adaptor on the R9M and using the Immortal T for both systems.
Installation
I actually think the FrSky R9M wins this one. Neither system is difficult to install. But the R9M is much cleaner when installed due to it fitting flush with the back of the Taranis. This means it can stay installed when it’s in the case. The Crossfire on the other hand is quite bulky; however it can work with other manufacturer’s transmitters, which is good for TBS, but not for a nice clean install.
Features
The Crossfire wins this one easily. The screen on the back makes setup changes a breeze. Plus it can go up to 2W power compared to 1W. Both systems feature an XT30 socket for external power. If you use 2S you can use the same power supply for both systems (the Crossfire can go up to 3S).
Cost
There’s no questions here, the R9 system is a lot more value for money than Crossfire. Even comparing the Micro Tx to the R9, which is a fairer comparison; I’d still give this to the R9. As you get a receiver with the R9M for less than the cost of the Crossfire Micro Tx. The cheaper cost of receivers make the savings even greater in the long term.
Firmware
CRSF 2 – R9 0
Crossfire wins hands down here. I’ve awarded 2 points here because of the experience I’ve personally had. I didn’t have the R9 through the dodgy firmware phase, so that’s not been accounted for.
Updates
The TBS Crossfire system updates are performed better and easier than with the R9, there’s no question here. With Crossfire, you plug the module into your computer with a USB cable and run the TBS Agent. This detects your product and lists all firmware for it. You select the latest version and flash it to the Crossfire module. The next time a receiver connects to the module, it will be updated over the air with the new firmware. It just works!
With the FrSky system, you have to download the firmware for the module and all the receivers you have. Copy them on to your Taranis. Then flash the module in the Taranis, followed by flashing each individual receiver in the back of the Taranis. If that receiver is buried in a model, good luck!
The firmware
The Crossfire firmware is easy to get hold of and update and gives you all the options out the box. However, the stock R9 firmware is pretty locked down. There is a solution for this called the Flex firmware. However it’s currently still new and buggy and you need to flash your Taranis with an unreleased/unsupported version of OpenTX (2.2.3). When the Flex firmware and OpenTX 2.2.3 are both released as stable platforms, this won’t be so much of an issue. But currently it loses FrSky a point.
Usability
Crossfire 2 – R9 1
Ease of use
Both systems are pretty simple to use so both get a point. The R9M is pretty much like just using the internal Taranis RF module. So if you are happy using that, the R9M will be a no-brainer. Just switch off the internal module and set the external to R9M. Then use the Taranis menu to change the settings. The crossfire is simple too. Just set the external module to CRSF, then do everything on the screen on the Crossfire.
Features
The Crossfire wins this hands down. Both systems can set power levels and get telemetry. But the Crossfire allows the receivers to be configured in way more detail. For instance, the Micro RX has 4 outputs. Each of these outputs can be set to do whatever you want. For example:
- Out 1 = CRSF TX
- Out 2 = CRSF RX
- Out 3 = Channel 7
- Out 4 = Channel 11.
Furthermore, the channels themselves can be configured in the receiver. So for example, channel 12 can output the LQ (RSSI) directly from the receiver. I’m only just scratching the surface. There are features like a lost model finder and frequency scanner. All in all, there’s simply more features and more control than the R9 system.
Conclusion
Crossfire 6 – R9 4
So going by the scores, the Crossfire is the winner. But, if you don’t need all the features that the Crossfire has to offer, the R9 system is a bargain. Especially at the current price of £30! So far, I think I’m going to use both systems. The R9 for the most part (as the R9 MM is cheaper than an R-XSR!). But the Crossfire for more cherished models or models with a more complex setup.