Servo Testing Methodology

Published by Mr. D on

In this document, I intend to layout the process for servo reviews and testing. This servo testing methodology is to make sure that all tests are performed to the same standards, ensuring the results can be compared.

General

Classes

The servos will be grouped by servo size classes. These are:

Less than 8gNano
8g to 16.9gSub-micro
17g to 26.9gMicro
27g to 39.9gMini
40g to 79.9gStandard
80g and heavierLarge

Due to the models that I fly, I will likely be testing mostly Sub-micro servos.

Voltages

Each test, with the exception of the visual inspection, centring, and endurance; will be performed for all supported voltage. I have a BEC that can output 5, 6, and 7.2 volts, which I will use initially. However, in the future, I may look to get a constant voltage power supply, for more accuracy.

Other

Other factors that may be useful for comparison, such as the cost of the servo at the time of the test, will be noted.

Centring Accuracy

A laser will be attached to the servo arm and aimed at a fixed location on a wall, with the servo centred. The centre of the servo’s pivot will be a set distance from the wall. The servo will then move full left, full right, then back to centre. The difference will be measured. The test will be performed 5 times, and an average taken.

Servo Speed

The servo speed will be measured using a laser speed trap. The gates will be placed at 60 degrees apart, at a set distance away from the pivot point. I hope to control the servo using the ESP32 that will be recording the laser speed gate, to ensure an accurate, comparable test. The test will proceed as follows:

  1. The servo will move from 1000 μs to 2000 μs, recording the time taken to move 60 degrees (30 degrees each side of centre)
  2. The will be a delay of 0.5 seconds (time tbc)
  3. The servo will then move from 2000 μs to 1000 μs, recording the time taken to move 60 degrees
  4. There will be a delay of 0.5 seconds, before performing step 1 again
  5. The passes will continue until there are 25 readings

The timing mechanism will record the current pass, fastest pass, slowest pass, and an average of the 25 passes. Though I understand that this data may not be comparable with manufacturers’ data. It will give a direct comparison between the servos tested.

Servo Torque

The servo will pull a linkage connected to a luggage scale. The clevis will be attached to the hole closest to 1cm from the pivot. I will read the maximum torque during the test, as the force held by the luggage scale. I will also check the video recording for a peek torque. The peek and sustained torques will be recorded.

Sweep

The ESP32 driven servo will sweep back and forth at a consistent speed. It will make 30 sweeps from minimum to maximum, then finally centre. We can use this test for a visual smoothness and range.

Amp Draw

I hope to also use the ESP32 for recording the current. I’ll test for stall current during the torque test. I will record the average current draw during the sweep test. Both current results will be stored.

Endurance

I will attach a weight to the servo. The servo will then cycle for 24 hours. If the servo is fine after the 24 hours, it gets a pass. I will attempt to monitor the current during this test, as if something fails, I should be able to detect the time that the failure occurred. The weight used is not going to be excessive. It should be within the average specs of the servo class. Weights TBC, but as an example:

Nano750 g
Sub-micro1000 g
Micro2000 g
Mini3000 g
Standard7000 g
Large40000 g

Visual Inspection

External

Externally, we can look at the quality of the materials used for the casing. We can also see if there is any slop.

Internal

In this section, the servo will be opened up so that we can take a look inside. We can use this to see the build materials used, including the gears and types of bearings. The visual inspection should be performed last. This ensures that the test will not be compromised by dismantling the servo. Also any damage during the testing can be surveyed.

Share:
Categories: Methodologies